• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Catch 54

Located in Selbyville, DE, Catch 54 is a popular cocktail bar and seafood restaurant known for its New American cuisine. With a diverse menu offering vegetarian options and a range of starters like the Deviled Eggs Mustard Cream and Hot Crab Dip, this spot is perfect for groups and families. Their salads feature fresh ingredients like shaved Brussels sprouts and baby kale, providing a healthy and flavorful dining experience. The restaurant also offers outdoor seating, a full bar, and happy hour specials, making it a great choice for a casual yet delicious dinner. Catch 54 truly has something for everyone to enjoy.

Catch 54: Reviews & Ratings

Tony J.
Tony J.

As you can see from my many prior reviews, this is our #1 favorite place for Sunday high noon happy hour with our usual many friends. I will summarize our many Sunday visits here from December through March. Tall Bill C. and young surfer dude Mike R. are two of our favorite bartenders. Tall Bill C. has been the bartender during the past several months although Bill recently started working at Macky's. We will miss Bill. Marlene and Will usually stop by to greet us. Faith retired recently so we will miss Faith. Criss always perfectly shucks our usual happy hour raw oysters. The oysters most recently have been from Craddock Creek, Virginia or Sodel Salts. Bill C. knows what our party of eight family and friends usually orders including our cocktails and happy hour food choices. In February they offered the grilled chicken cordon bleu grilled cheese sandwich for $18. I wish the sandwich had more chicken, ham and cheese even if it were a higher price. I usually enjoy steamed shrimp or chicken wings with blue cheese. I most recently ordered the daily special Swedish meatballs for $24. The Swedish sauce was tasty, but the Swedish meatballs did not taste Swedish enough for my taste. I also have been enjoying my Burnish Loose Lips Sink Ships draft American stout (6% ABV) for $7. I recently have been enjoying the happy hour chicken wings with blue cheese for $11 rather than my other favorite happy hour steamed shrimp. My bills for two of us usually range between $71-101 excluding gratuities depending upon what food we order and drink. Bill C. most recently applied our Indian River School 10% discount to non-happy hour items. See my many pics. Surfer dude Mike and Nick returned here most recently in March. Both served us very well. Both Mike and Nick know how to handle us. Will and Marlene also usually stop by to greet us.

April L.
April L.

What a gem! Love this restaurant in Fenwick. Great happy hour from 4-6. Cute bar surrounded by a few high top table. I tried the buck a shuck oysters. They were delicious! The spicy Rita for $8 was great to was down those oysters. I also tried the cheeseburger. It was cooked to a perfect medium rare and very flavorful. I highly recommend if you're in the Fenwick area. The also have seating upstairs with nice views of the bay.

Stephanie S.
Stephanie S.

Wowee, this was delicious. Arrived after the boat parade in December. Was seated fairly quickly at a table overlooking the water. It was dark but there are enough lights around to see a little bit. We started with the Oysters Rockefeller and they were phenomenal. For our mains. We got the chowder and the rainbow trout special. Both were incredibly delicious down to the last bite. For desert, we had the apple crisp which was just ok but still good. Can't wait to come back! There is a tiny parking lot out front (maybe 10 cars), street parking, or a bigger lot a little bit down the road.

John G.
John G.

Becoming another favorite we had a party of four and reservations for 4:30 we arrived a little early and were seated immediately! Another great dinner for us. My BIL had the Salmon which came with a chutney. My SIL decided on the Southern Fried Chicken very tender lightly breaded and crispy With whipped potatoes and a bacon corn gravy in the side and farm beans. My better half had Buttermilk Fried Shrimp Salt Fries , Coleslaw, Cocktail Sauce of course she ordered a side of melted butter! I ordered the Jumbo Shrimp and Parmasean Grits Andouille Sausage , Trinity , Tomato- Beer Jus & Rosemary Butter! Another great meal for all of us! Great friendly service and you can't beat the views of the Bays in Fenwick Island BUTTERMILK FRIED JUMBO SHRIMP

Kim M.
Kim M.

We came for dinner and were seated upstairs via the spiral staircase, however, there is an elevator. Our server was awesome. She was friendly and showed us the specialty drink options and told us about the appetizers. As always, we ordered the oysters and they were so good with no shells! The deviled eggs were good and we also loved the calamari. I had the crab cakes and loved them and the cucumber salad was so fresh. Our other dinner orders were a rice bowl with an egg on top, a chicken Caesar salad, tuna entree and shrimp with clams. Every single person absolutely loved everything they ordered. For dessert my husband ordered the lemons cake - I said I only was only going to have a couple bites but ended up eating almost all of it! The service here could not have been any better. The place is beautiful with seating upstairs and down and plenty of parking. Can't wait to come back!

Ryan M.
Ryan M.

Seafood was super fresh. The clams and the fried shrimp were two of my favorites. The staff was friendly and attentive. Our food came out really quick which was nice. The views of the water are stunning and the outside seating is definitely the way to go.

Rebecca H.
Rebecca H.

This is a lovely restaurant on the bay. The pineapple martini and espresso martini were refreshing and light. The oysters were delicious and fresh. The service was good and the restaurant had clean, open layout with lots of windows. It was really nice to step outside to enjoy the view of the bay afterwards.

Judy R.
Judy R.

An amazing local restaurant with beautiful views of the Assowoman Bay in Delaware. Their food is always simple but delicious! Consistent every time with a great Happy Hour and very friendly professional staff. Off season they have specials every day of the week. If you at the beach make sure you it's in your plans to stop in and have some great food! They post on FB they daily specials.

Location

  • Catch 54
    38931 Madison Ave Selbyville, DE 19975 Hotline: (302) 436-8600

Located in Selbyville, Delaware, Catch 54 is a delightful combination of Cocktail Bars, New American cuisine, and Seafood. This hidden gem offers a plethora of amenities including Takeout, Reservations, Vegetarian Options, and parking facilities. The atmosphere at Catch 54 is casual with moderate noise levels, making it a perfect spot for a relaxed dining experience.

With a focus on fresh seafood, Catch 54's menu features an array of starters like Deviled Eggs with Mustard Cream, Jumbo Lump Crab, and Buttermilk Fried Calamari served with a zesty red sauce and lemon. The salads are equally enticing, with options like Shaved Brussels Sprouts with Pecorino, Pistachios, and a Honey Vinaigrette, or the Baby Iceberg Salad adorned with bacon, bleu cheese, and pickled onions.

As a food reviewer, I have had the pleasure of sampling the dishes at Catch 54 and I must say, each bite was a delight. The flavors were vibrant, the ingredients fresh, and the presentation impeccable. The attention to detail in each dish was evident, and it truly elevated the dining experience.

If you find yourself in Selbyville, Delaware, do not miss the opportunity to dine at Catch 54. Your taste buds will thank you.